Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix is a handcrafted, concentrated syrup that brings a bar-quality Old Fashioned home. I get a balanced profile from it: bitters come through first, orange peel adds lift, tart cherry rounds it out, and warm spice finishes the sip. I like that it keeps the drink whiskey-forward instead of turning it into a sweet cocktail.
Key takeaways
Balanced, familiar profile: bitters bite up front, orange peel brightness, tart cherry depth, and a warm spiced finish.
Simple, consistent ratio: 2 oz bourbon or rye + 1/4 oz syrup, stirred with ice for fast results.
Batch-friendly size: 16 oz bottle works well for batching, and the label claim of up to 64 cocktails supports party planning.
Dietary/label highlights:USDA Organic, gluten-free, non-GMO, OU Kosher, and moderate sugar/calories per serving.
Concentrated texture: thick syrup means a small pour goes a long way; warming the bottle slightly or stirring longer helps it pour and blend smoothly.
Bar-Quality Old Fashioned Flavor at Home
This handcrafted Old Fashioned syrup gets me close to a bar-quality pour without hauling out multiple bottles. The profile lands balanced and familiar, with bitters bite, bright orange peel, tart cherry, and a warm spice finish. A few customers even say it turns home cocktails into top-notch creations, and one reviewer notes it tastes like Steen’s Syrup.
How I use it for consistent results
I keep it simple, then adjust to the whiskey. Here’s what works for me:
Start with 2 oz bourbon or rye, then add a small measure of syrup and stir with ice.
Lean rye if I want sharper bitters and spice.
Use an expressed orange peel to push aroma and balance sweetness.
Pair with dessert snacks like hazelnut chocolates for an easy nightcap setup.
Makes 64 Classic Cocktails – Large 16oz bottle yields 64 consistently balanced Old Fashioneds. Perfect for entertaining, batching, or stocking your bar with bar-quality mix.
Handcrafted & Balanced – 5g sugar and 20 calories per serving. Made with USDA Organic, Gluten-Free, Non-GMO, OU Kosher ingredients including tart cherry, orange peel, and spice.
Fast, Consistent Results – Skip the muddling. Mix 2 oz Bourbon or Rye with ¼ oz syrup and ice for a smooth, reliable Old Fashioned in seconds.
Versatile Cocktail Mixer – Great with Bourbon, Rye, or creative twists using rum, tequila, or Mezcal. Use in classic cocktails or bold mixology recipes.
Perfect for Home Bars & Gifting – Ideal for whiskey lovers, hosts, or bartenders. Makes a thoughtful gift for Father’s Day, holidays, or birthday celebrations.
Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix – Handcrafted Old Fashioned Syrup with Bitters, Orange Peel & Tart Cherry – Gluten-Free – Makes 64 Cocktails (16oz, 1-Pack) – Just Add Bourbon or Rye
This image is property of Amazon.com.
Fast, Consistent Cocktails with a Simple Ratio
I like this mix because it removes the fussy steps that slow an Old Fashioned down. I skip muddling and stick to a repeatable build that tastes the same every time. The ratio is simple: 2 oz Bourbon or Rye, 1/4 oz syrup, plus ice. I stir, strain, and I’m done in seconds.
Batch-friendly speed for entertaining
For parties, I treat the 16oz bottle like a batching tool. I can pre-measure a round, keep my bar clean, and still serve drinks that don’t drift sweet or bitter. Here’s how I keep it consistent:
Pre-chill glasses so dilution stays controlled.
Stir each drink 15–20 seconds over solid ice for the same texture.
Use a jigger for the 1/4 oz syrup so every pour matches.
Scale up easily: 8 drinks = 16 oz Bourbon or Rye + 2 oz syrup.
The label claim that it makes 64 cocktails also makes the math easy when I’m planning for a crowd.
Practical pairing notes
I’ll reach for rye when I want extra spice, and bourbon when I want a rounder finish. For a snack pairing, I’ll sometimes set out assorted truffles to match the drink’s sweetness.
Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix – Handcrafted Old Fashioned Syrup with Bitters, Orange Peel & Tart Cherry – Gluten-Free – Makes 64 Cocktails (16oz, 1-Pack) – Just Add Bourbon or Rye
This image is property of Amazon.com.
Organic, Dietary-Friendly Ingredients
I like that this mix keeps the ingredient story clean while still tasting like a proper Old Fashioned. The label leans into real-world dietary needs without turning the drink into a sugar bomb. I also appreciate that it’s proudly made in America, which helps when I’m buying for gifting or events and want consistent sourcing.
What I look for on the label
Here’s what stands out to me for everyday drinking and hosting:
USDA Organic for a cleaner baseline when I’m mixing drinks often.
Gluten-Free, which keeps it easy for mixed groups.
Non-GMO for anyone who prefers that standard in pantry staples.
OU Kosher, useful when I’m planning for broader dietary observance.
Per serving, 5g sugar and 20 calories, so the cocktail stays balanced instead of syrupy.
I usually pair it with a full-proof bourbon or rye, then adjust dilution with ice rather than adding extra sweeteners. For a snack pairing, I’ll sometimes lean into hazelnut chocolates to match the warm spice notes.
Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix – Handcrafted Old Fashioned Syrup with Bitters, Orange Peel & Tart Cherry – Gluten-Free – Makes 64 Cocktails (16oz, 1-Pack) – Just Add Bourbon or Rye
This image is property of Amazon.com.
Value, Concentration, and Texture Notes
I treat this mixer as a concentrated component, so a small pour goes a long way. That’s why many buyers call it a good value, since I can stretch the bottle while keeping the drink whiskey-forward and consistent. I start light, stir, then add drops until the balance lands.
How I handle thickness in the glass
Texture feedback varies, and I get why: it can pour like a very thick syrup. I keep it smooth with a few habits:
Warm the bottle in my hands for 20–30 seconds before pouring.
Measure with a barspoon, then stir longer over a big cube.
Add a splash of water first if it clings to the glass.
Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix – Handcrafted Old Fashioned Syrup with Bitters, Orange Peel & Tart Cherry – Gluten-Free – Makes 64 Cocktails (16oz, 1-Pack) – Just Add Bourbon or Rye
This image is property of Amazon.com.
Versatile Mixer Beyond Whiskey + Giftable
I treat this cocktail mixer as a shortcut to consistent flavor. It clicks fast with bourbon and rye, but I also use it as a base for riffs when I want something different without rebuilding a recipe from scratch. A darker rum version leans into baking spice and caramel notes. Tequila turns it brighter and snappier, while mezcal adds smoke that reads like a bar-style twist.
How I use it across spirits
I keep a few repeatable setups so experimentation stays controlled:
Bourbon: I aim for a classic profile, then adjust sweetness with a small splash of soda water.
Rye: I lean into spice, then add an expressed orange peel for lift.
Rum: I choose an aged rum and finish with a dash of aromatic bitters if I want extra depth.
Tequila: I stick to reposado and add a grapefruit peel for an herbal-citrus edge.
Mezcal: I pour slightly less mezcal and add a cherry garnish to balance the smoke.
Home bar value and gifting
I like it for quick hosting and it looks giftable for Father’s Day, holidays, and birthdays. It also pairs well with a simple add-on like hazelnut chocolates in a small basket.
Bartender’s Secret Sauce USDA Organic Old Fashioned Mix – Handcrafted Old Fashioned Syrup with Bitters, Orange Peel & Tart Cherry – Gluten-Free – Makes 64 Cocktails (16oz, 1-Pack) – Just Add Bourbon or Rye
This image is property of Amazon.com.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Some of the links in this article are "affiliate links", a link with a special tracking code. This means if you click on an affiliate link and purchase the item, we will receive an affiliate commission.The item's price is the same whether or not there is an affiliate link. Regardless, we only recommend products or services we believe will add value to our readers.By using our affiliate links, you help support our Website, and we genuinely appreciate it.
From: Boulder, Colorado. Environmental science grad who checks materials, packaging, and whether “eco” is actually meaningful or just green-colored plastic.
